Forgot your password?
That’s what people are saying after Hannah Montana star Miley Cyrus sat for some revealing pics during a Vanity Fair photo shoot. These pictures have caused big drama with Miley’s fans.The photos were taken by famous celeb photographer Annie Leibovitz and were intended to be artsy and natural, but some people are saying that they are too racy (see above). Miley’s entire back is exposed but a sheet is in place to cover her front. Not incredibly scandalous, but Miley’s career is based on her squeaky clean reputation.Vanity Fair and Annie Leibovitz say they had the OK from Miley’s parents and handlers and even discussed the photos with Miley beforehand. At the time, Miley was interviewed by a Vanity Fair reporter who asked her about the photos. He says she thought they were fine. But Miley later said that once she saw the photos and the article, she was really embarrassed about the way the pictures turned out and that she never wanted to upset her fans.So what do you think? Did Miley go too far? Is this a whole lot of drama over nothing? Or did Vanity Fair take advantage of Miley? Did Miley mess up her good girl image or is she trying to just have “the best of both worlds?”Shout out, girlies, and give us your opinion below.
BY ANDREA T. ON 4/29/2008 12:57:00 PM 633 COMMENTS
ok, yes. miley went 2 far. it totally messed up her image. all of the little girls are gonna c it and say, "Mommie? Why is Hannah Montana without any clothes?" I'm a Miley fan myself and I think that the photo-shoot was a bad idea. I'm sorry Miley, but that's way more than I ever wanted to c of you. ~PLEASE READ MY OPINION!!!!!! polkadot111094
Posted by: polkadot111094 on 4/29/2008 4:13:23 PM
to honest, i dont like miley cyrus at all and im not surprised that she posed for their pics. even though i dont like her, i still hope she wont become the next linsey lohan or anything.
Posted by: label-free♥ on 4/29/2008 4:15:52 PM
erod1234 its not too grown up. im 11, and its actualy something ppl shood no about. miley is being a fool, and needs to stop. her and vanessa are already of the edge, theyll just b going down hill from now on....terrible
Posted by: apocalypticagirl on 4/29/2008 4:16:05 PM
not only am i disapointed in miley but her parents as well. miley is fifteen and can make her own choices but her parents allowed it. im really mad. she was a huge role model for my lil sis and now shes all like why would she do that, i thought she was a good girl. and i agree.uggg that makes me mad
Posted by: dancechickj23 on 4/29/2008 4:17:11 PM
i think this picture is beautiful but she should have waited until she was older to do this; on her other pictures she was stupid but she is a teenager everybody does stupid things, she probably just doesn't know how many 6-13 year old girls look up to her and wants to feel like she's not another child star disneys goin to throw away
Posted by: mystic on 4/29/2008 4:17:46 PM
i thought that for once there would be a celibrity role modle we could look up too but i guess they all turn out the same when they start young
Posted by: dancechickj23 on 4/29/2008 4:18:15 PM
i think she has, but not in this photo. have you seen the ones where she's showing off her bra? i mean THATS just crap. but this picture.. i agree with what the photographer said, about it being an 'artsy' picture. i see the way that its kind of old fashioned looking. but please, miley, stay clean. please?
Posted by: ♥ELPHiE♥ on 4/29/2008 4:19:11 PM
From the first time her show came out I never liked her. I didn't even like her dad (even if i am not old enough to really kno him). Mily is going to be the new Britney Spears. She was sweet in the beginning and then before you know she starts slipping. Yes, she MAY have SOME talent but is definatly RICH she is going to clapse. Let's hope it doesn't take her until she is 30 to realize what she does is wrong. Then again getting paid a 7 digit check does make you do things that you would have never thought u would do.
Posted by: aliengirl on 4/29/2008 4:21:58 PM
this isn't such a big deal she is NOT like Brittney Spears AT ALL, the worst thing miley can do at this age is what Vannessa Hudgens did, or getting pregnant. sure its not the greatest picture, but you guys need to be mature and realize that there ARE pictures of naked people in scluptures and paintins to chilax
Posted by: sportsgirl25 a.k.a i luv johnny depp on 4/29/2008 4:23:06 PM
What do you mean people look up to her? I think her singing is horrible, she needs to work on her pitch BIG TIME. I would not want to look up to someone who does things before they think. SO WHAT IF YOU ARE PAID 1,000,000 dollars THINK! THE MONEY ISN'T GOING TO GET YOU FAR WHEN YOU ARE GOING TO BE BLAMED FOR EVERYTHING.
Posted by: aliengirl on 4/29/2008 4:23:31 PM
UGH. i hate miley cyrus and this is no surprise she did this. first of all, she is too young to be in vanity fair. second, shes a poseur. she says shes a "good girl" but shes not. shes mean on youtube. (miley and mandy show. she made fun of selena and demi) she wears clothes that are wayyy to old for a 15 year old. i never liked her in the first place.
Posted by: chichippie on 4/29/2008 2:51:25 PM
I think that Miley didn't really mean for that to be put out in pubic. She is a good person and i respect that.
Posted by: stylediva11 on 4/29/2008 2:51:49 PM
okay i dont think THIS pic is too terrible. she isn't showing anything, and many people have posed like this before. i HAVE seen the other pics miley's getting in trouble for ... and they're not okay ! there are pics of her pulling down her shirt to show her bra, and sitting on some guys lap with her shirt practically off. THAT is not okay !
Posted by: sapphire176 on 4/29/2008 2:53:52 PM
My opinion is that she is over doing it. no need to go that far!
Posted by: Sparklebunny11 on 4/29/2008 2:55:34 PM
i have to say that i think miley really needs to cool it down a bit. but i can also see how in that photo shoot situation, where everyone is telling you that you look great and you're with a world-famous photographer, you can get caught up in all the excitement.she apologized probably because she realized how it looked to the "real" world. you have to keep in mind that just because 8-year-olds like miley so do older audiences and miley is not 8 herself. all in all i dont think she will end up quit as poorly as ms. spears and lohan
Posted by: strwbrryblonde25 on 4/29/2008 2:57:08 PM
I think she acts WAY to old for her age. It's mostly little kids who look up to her and she shouldn't be doing that stuff in front of the camara.
Posted by: satchmo3 on 4/29/2008 3:02:30 PM
Miley is trying to grow up too fast. She needs to slow down and act her age. In an acrticle about this, it said her parents were mortified.
Posted by: erod1234 on 4/29/2008 3:03:55 PM
people say she is the next lindsey lohan but she is starting to act like brittney or jamie spears!!!not good at all. i want to know what her 'rents say about this!!
Posted by: kccutie1 on 4/29/2008 3:04:12 PM
That picture is disgusting! What did it say about her in the article anyway?
Posted by: calivolleyball95 on 4/29/2008 3:04:26 PM
I think this article is too adult for this magazine. 10 year olds are reading this, GL!
Posted by: erod1234 on 4/29/2008 3:04:52 PM
ok. this does not surprise me AT ALL. ive seen worse pics of miley. wayyy worse. those pics have been out since, like september! so i dont get what the big deal is. this is nothing compared to what she has done in the past.
Posted by: LovePINK on 4/29/2008 3:05:01 PM
i think miley went way to far with her pictures she really is starting to act like a 25 year old and shes only 15 she needs to stop taking in appropriate pictures!!!!!
Posted by: yafit15 on 4/29/2008 3:06:10 PM
Why would she do that? I'm sick and tired of people saying "Oh, it's her life, let her do it because everyone does it anyway!" So what if other people do it?!?! They shouldn't. God didn't create us to show off ourselves, and that's just what she's doing! Her parents are to blame, too. Why didn't they step in and say something, like that its gone waay to far? They probably just thought that it would make her appear more mature or something. Its not artistic either. Plus, it makes her look all...goth. I read part of an article in J-14 magazine where she said that she would never be like Brittany Spears. I doubt that. And you can't even say that it's what happens to all Hollywood stars, because I could list so many girls and young women who were in a very popular show or movie, and are leading perfectly clean lives. Way to go Miley, good luck trying to "Start All Over".
Posted by: milkel91 on 4/29/2008 3:07:19 PM
i think that it was just blown outta proportion. i mean, it was supposed 2 b an artistic photo, not a playboy pic. but ppl thought it was. wow
Posted by: redsoxchica4444 on 4/29/2008 6:06:17 PM
**MOD**MOD*********** is this wat love is? when u cant stop smiling, and u draw hearts all over ur books, wen u hear ur song, u sing @ the top of ur lungs, while smileing so much that it sounds like ur dying.
Hey there
aww, thats cute. if that feels like love for you, then it is! "*Sarah
Posted by: redsoxchica4444 on 4/29/2008 6:07:07 PM
ok so she could be a little more covered near her back, but BIG DEAL!!! every teen girl takes stupid photos with her freinds or whatever!!! and mabey the bra was a bit too much, but big deal, its not like she flashed the whole world like vanessa hudgens. the fact shes with her dad in some is a lil weird, but it just looks like shes sitting on his lap! whats wrong with that? i mean c'mon everybody makes mistakes! hers just happened to end up all over the news! and thats a part of her song!
Posted by: missyrissy on 4/29/2008 6:08:12 PM
AND THIS IS NO WHERE NEAR THE SPEARS GIRLS OR LOHAN FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!!!!!
Posted by: missyrissy on 4/29/2008 6:09:26 PM
I think Miley needs to tone it down a bit. She's still cool though.
Posted by: CuteCupcake on 4/29/2008 6:11:33 PM
ok they arent that bad but why is she in vanity fair, old people look at that magazine not tweensi think she wont last more than 2 years in disney channel , if not less
Posted by: colombianaj93 on 4/29/2008 6:12:24 PM
Please don't all overreact, Miley exercised poor judgment with these photos, but don't you think the fact that the photographer is partly to blame? Even asking Miley to pose for a shot like that? Miley is a minor, and it should be illegal to ask minors to pose like that! Also, DONT shun Miley for what she's done! I am always going to like Miley, and it's not fair to her to say what you girls are saying!
Posted by: bunnylover613 on 4/29/2008 6:13:05 PM
Has anyone read Twilight? I LOVE it!!!!!!
Posted by: CuteCupcake on 4/29/2008 6:14:02 PM
i use to like her but now shes gotten bad.... all u people who think that those pics werent bad are truly mistaken and if she really is a christian like she said she is, she should NEVER have even thought of takening those pictures.
Posted by: peppermintmocha123 on 4/29/2008 6:14:23 PM
i personally think that people give her too much credit. she cant really even sing and her show seems really fake.
Posted by: ylimexxx654321 on 4/29/2008 6:17:10 PM
This is SO not Miley. She's just going down the Black Hole of the Media, like almost every other teenage pop star. I'm dissapointed. But it's true. SHe looks very freaky. They made her exetremely pale, and her lipstick is blood-colored. Very creepy. ***MOD*** What do you think???? ***MOD***
Posted by: christianwriterchic101 on 4/29/2008 6:20:38 PM
Ummm celeberity train wreak in traning! She needs to look up some info on what happened to brittney spears and learn from it! Gosh she is really starting to annoy me :]
Posted by: soccergirlyrayray on 4/29/2008 6:23:31 PM
JellyBean ♥!!*whistle*!!♥- How can the pics be altered if Miley admitted to them? She apolygized a lot. It would be really hard to alter a pic like that. It has to be her and it is.
Posted by: Kitty1753 on 4/29/2008 6:23:56 PM
milk&honey_baby, It's totally okay to do pictures of that, but when you have the whole world looking at you from your backyard, you got to think about what your doing. How do you think the 7 year olds feel when they see hannah montana with just a sheet on?
Posted by: erod1234 on 4/29/2008 3:08:46 PM
yeah , she a little too young to be taking photos that are this revealing.
Posted by: mychemlover on 4/29/2008 3:10:39 PM
i think it's too much drama over nothing. it's a picture! it wasn't HER idea to pose this way. sheesh. give her a break, shes like, what, 15? give her a break! it's a lot of pressure and we all make mistakes
Posted by: projectrunwaygirl on 4/29/2008 3:11:43 PM
OMG leave her alone! Those pictures are fine! I really think that if her family and espically she was ok with it- everyone else should be!!!! I thinl some of the pictures make her look bad- not bad as in racy- but like it kinda looked like she was dead in the picture (above)! But seriously whats wrong w/ that!?!? LEAVE HER ALONE!
Posted by: sccrstarsmiley on 4/29/2008 3:13:55 PM
the pic isnt that bad but w/the other pics it just shows shes tryin 2 grow up 2 fast plus she has 2 realize that she has like millions of fans that look up 2 her/\. when u bcome a star u have 2 watch wat u do bcuz of ur fans. miley needs 2 act like shes 15 not 25
Posted by: kenigirlxo2 on 4/29/2008 3:15:18 PM
i really don't like miley cyrus. one of these days she is going too go to far and end her whole career.-
Posted by: mychemlover on 4/29/2008 3:15:44 PM
i think it is not only mileys fault it is partially her parents/handelers fault because when they saw the photo they were ok w/ it but it also partially mileys fault b cuz if she felt uncomfortable w/ it she shouldve said NO after the miley look alike this was a terrible way 2 control damage
Posted by: live life love life cuz you only have 1 life on 4/29/2008 3:16:35 PM
NO ON UYUBE I SAW IT ON ANOTHER ANGLE AND SHE WORE JEANS AND A BLANKET
Posted by: friends r 4 eva on 4/29/2008 3:16:36 PM
i agree with kee, miley has gone way too far, i seriously think that she is going to be exactly like britney spears and lindsay lohan. innocent in the beginning and then turn bad. it's especially bad since she has so many young fans who she's teaching to do stuff like this. it's just sick to teach them that kind of stuff. that picture makes her look so horrible! i bet she's going to lose tons of fans!
Posted by: calivolleyball95 on 4/29/2008 3:16:38 PM
kee the fotos of her on da guys lap were a look alike not really her dont blame her 4 wat sum1 else did
Posted by: live life love life cuz you only have 1 life on 4/29/2008 3:17:30 PM
are you kiddin` me? i am not suprised. and i think it is TOTALLY unexeptable. she walked into hollywood having some common sence, but hollywood has had it wrung out of her. concidering she stars on disney channel, where little girls get obsessed in the miley cyrus drama, this is a HORRIBLE role model. they will want to be like her, and who knows WHAT they'll do.
Posted by: ieatedchocolate on 4/29/2008 3:18:03 PM
miley looks like a vampire with blood dripping down her cheek behind her black hair. no kind of picture that ur just behind a blanket is a good picture especially if you have tons of 4 year old fans!!! this is sad.
Posted by: calivolleyball95 on 4/29/2008 3:19:14 PM
kee, your my new best friend. i ttly agree w/ what you said.
Posted by: ieatedchocolate on 4/29/2008 3:19:17 PM
Why can't miley have stayed the same. she used to be a good role model now shes just a model. maybe the magazine took advantage of her but thats no excuse. she agreed with having them take the pics. i am disappointed in her parents to. who would let a teen do that. stupid miley.
Posted by: kenzswims on 4/29/2008 4:28:27 PM
If you could be stuck on a desert island with any celebrity, who would it be?
SECRET CODE: SO SMOOTH DOWNLOAD the May giveaway calendar!WIN a campership to Power Chord Academy!
SECRET CODE:
SO SMOOTH
DOWNLOAD the May giveaway calendar!WIN a campership to Power Chord Academy!
Looking for some fab page-turners to fill your sunny summer days? Whether you’re in the mood for an action-packed adventure or a riveting romance, Penguin Young Readers' got ya covered!
CLICK HERE TO GET STARTED!