SIGN UP
FORGOT MY PASSWORD
GUYS

16 fun in the sun summertime dates

MORE
  • GUYS MAIN
  • GET A BF
    • CRUSH MUCH?
    • ICE BREAKERS
  • DATING 101
    • DUDES DECODED
    • CUTE DATE IDEAS
    • SPLITSVILLE
  • ASK BILL & DAVE
  • DEAR CAROL
  • WHAT GUYS THINK
  • SWEETIE
  • MEANIE
ADVICE

My dad is sexually abusing me. How can I tell my mom?

MORE
  • ADVICE MAIN
  • IN THE NEWS
  • DEAR CAROL
  • FAMILY
  • FRIENDS
  • SCHOOL
  • TOUGH STUFF
  • ON THE JOB
    • GET STARTED
    • BABYSITTING
    • GOAL GETTER
    • DREAM JOB
  • DO GOOD
    • GET INSPIRED
    • TAKE ACTION
FUN STUFF

25 things to do before school lets out

MORE
  • FUN STUFF MAIN
  • STAR SIGNS
  • BLUSH MUCH?
  • SURVEY SAYS
  • CLUBS
  • ADVICE QUEENS
  • CRAFTS
  • RECIPES
  • CONTESTS
  • WINNERS
  • ROCK YOUR WEEKEND
  • YOU WROTE IT
ENTERTAINMENT

It’s puppy love with The Last Dogs: Dark Waters

MORE
  • ENTERTAINMENT MAIN
  • GOSSIP
  • STAR STYLE
  • GL EXCLUSIVES
  • EDITOR'S PICKS
  • BOOK CLUB
STYLE

Dream on with a DIY dream board

MORE
  • STYLE MAIN
  • FASHION
    • CUTE & CHEAP
    • STYLE 911
    • TRENDS WE HEART
  • BEAUTY
    • BEAUTY SPY
    • BEAUTY TRENDS
    • BEAUTY 911
    • HAIR STYLES
    • HAIR TIPS
    • SKINCARE
  • HOW TO
  • FAB UP YOUR LIFE
HEALTH & FITNESS

Short shorts-approved moves for toned legs

MORE
  • HEALTH & FITNESS MAIN
  • WORKOUTS
  • RECIPES
  • EAT RIGHT
  • HEALTHY STUFF WE HEART
  • YOUR BOD
    • SKIN
    • HAIR
    • BOOBS
    • DOWN THERE
    • PERIODS, PERIOD
    • EVERYTHING ELSE
QUIZZES

Who's your celeb style clone?

MORE
MAG

Show some #GLcrew love, babes!

MORE
  • MAG MAIN
  • INSIDE THIS ISSUE
  • COVER SHOOT
  • BEHIND THE SCENES
  • BE IN THE MAG
  • EDITOR'S BLOG
  • OUR BOOKS
  • ABOUT US
VIDEO

Bella Thorne rocks WAT-AAH!'s Move Your Body Flash Mob

MORE
avatar

Becca G.

is modding

Lauren R.

is modding

 
 
 

GL PROFILES

More Friends = More Fun

MY ACCOUNT

MY PROFILE

CREATE A PROFILE

 
 

GL
Tweets !

AN HOUR AGO How to know when taking a risk is the right thing to do: Click Here!

13 HOURS AGO The 7 caffeine-laced products that could disappear: Click Here!

14 HOURS AGO Treat your toes to an at home pro pedi: Click Here!

 
 
 
Girl's Life Newsletters

sponsored links

ENTERTAINMENT | EDITOR'S PICKS

46 Comments | Add Yours

It's time to decide: Edward or Jacob?


 

Check these out, too...

  • 8 BFF Reads: Characters' friendships you won't want to miss
  • OMG celeb moments of the week
  • Tune up your summer concert wardrobe with these picks
  • Get gorgeous spring date night makeup
  • It's puppy love with The Last Dogs: Dark Waters
With the premiere of Breaking Dawn Part 2 so close, we’ve realized that it’s finally time for us to decide which team we’re on. But here at GL, we’re having a lot of trouble doing just that!

 

There are multiple reasons why we love each of them, but we are completely torn. Read on to see our arguments for each, and be sure to sound off on what team you’re on and why GL should join you.

 

He’s Got Vampiric Charm

On one hand, Edward Cullen is totally romantic. No matter what happens, we know he’ll always love Bella. He tried to kill himself when he thought she had died after all! We also love how old-fashioned he can be…seeing as he’s actually 109 years old.

 

But at the same time, we remember how cold and distant he could be. Who wants a BF who constantly switches his mood? Also, he totally ditched Bella in New Moon. Sure, he thought he was keeping her safe by leaving, but it was still absolutely heartbreaking. Is he capable of leaving her again, and if so, could we truly be Team Edward in that case?

 

Fallin’ For my Bestie

Bella and Jake being together is just like that super cute I’m-in-love-with-my-best-friend scenario…except, of course, Jacob is a werewolf! We love how Jake totally picked up the pieces for Bells when Edward left. And how adorable is it that she thinks of him as her personal sunshine?!

 

However, we have to remember that Jake also turned his back on Bella at one point. She was so fragile and just getting over Edward, we couldn’t believe he’d do such a thing. Once again, it was all to protect Bella. But seriously, how come none of these guys can stick around and really be there for her? Plus, with Jake, Bella just doesn’t feel the same amount of love as she feels for Edward. Is it really meant to be? If all Bella and Jake will ever be is a fling, it’d be tough to side with Team Jacob.

 

Which team are YOU on, and why should GL join in? Blog about it, babes.

BY KATIE LEMON ON 11/13/2012 12:00:00 AM

POSTED IN entertainment, movies, Twilight, movies we love, Celebs, Robert Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Breaking Dawn

< PREVIOUS   NEXT >   

46 Comments | Add Yours
SORT: OLDEST FIRST | NEWEST FIRST
 

Everyone is saying stuff like, team Jacob because he was there for her in New Moon or team Edward because he is so protective and would die for her. I am Team Edward but was REALLY disappointed to see that they made Jacob look better than Edward. It just annoys me.

report

by jmtkwalshgirl on 2/2/2013 6:07:20 PM

 
 

can i have jacob please? i HATE kristin stewart and she doesn't deserve him. I don't even like Bella as the character. she is super weird and psycho and cold.

report

by kpianoplayer on 11/17/2012 3:57:20 PM

 
 

ive never liked the twilight series but jacob is wayyy better then edward. edward is so ugly. when he took his shirt off in 1 of the movies i almost gagged.

report

by fearless;) on 11/16/2012 10:57:15 PM

 
 

I say team edward because if Jacob every got mad she would get a bad scar on her face

report

by lucylou19 on 11/15/2012 7:29:18 PM

 
 

TEAM JACOB all the way! I think Edward is way to obsessed with Bella. Whereas Jacob would do anything to protect her. Plus, since when do vampires sparkle like a princess???

report

by sydneylexis on 11/14/2012 6:13:27 PM

 
 

oh geez i like them both but i'm gonna have to say Edward

report

by myfatsquirrel on 11/14/2012 4:00:38 PM

 
 



mod! so I've been friends with this guy since Monday and I don't "like" him and he dosent "like" me but we've texted a couple of times but I'm always like afraid to text him first like I don't wanna bother him him and we don't ever speak in school not one word and I feel awkward. help!?!!

 

hey girl! WHOA you've only been friends for two days?! take it easy on yourself, you barely know each other. also, you should totally be talking in person if you're texting each other. relationships, friendships or romantic, should happen in real life as well.

xoxo 


Katie L.

report

by ladyinlike on 11/14/2012 3:01:36 PM

 
 

Im team Jacward i like both and woudent it be totally awesome if they combined Edward's personality with Jacob's body!!!!!!!!!!! Smile ;)

report

by flammer3 on 11/13/2012 8:58:03 PM

 
 

Well you can't pick team jacob because there is no way he will love Bella, he imprinted on their daughter, so it's like, he will love her but not like that. She (Bella) says in new moon how jacob is like a brother, yea she considered Jacob being the one after edward but she always considered them almost like family. Now they are. Edward and Bella, Renesme and Jacob. They will be family if jacob marries Renesme, They are all meant to be in each others life. You can't say what if Jacob, because it can't be, no matter how I feel towards Jacob (because he is beautiful and warm and he held bella in a way of love) he was destined to be with renesme.

report

by andsothelionfellinlovewiththelamb on 11/13/2012 8:34:56 PM

 
 

Solution! Bella can have Edward since she already married him and everything, and I can have Jacob!

report

by cheerfulcheer on 11/13/2012 8:22:30 PM

 
 

Team Edward

report

by girlio93485 on 11/13/2012 7:30:42 PM

 
 

Team Jacob

report

by msawesome on 11/13/2012 7:17:59 PM

 
 

Jacob always

report

by pinklol56 on 11/13/2012 7:04:05 PM

 
 

Neither. I think that she should be friends with them both. I think GL should join in because it is true they are both good but have their faults. Not disrespecting anyones opinion. Just mine.

report

by hgrules on 11/13/2012 6:59:37 PM

 
 

of couse it is goimg to be team ed he is so hot and jacod is hot to but there is just something about ed that maks us all like him right or i am i just losing it lol Smile

report

by als2peacocks on 11/13/2012 6:44:29 PM

 
 

TEAM PEETA!

report

by triplethreat335 on 11/13/2012 6:39:40 PM

 
 

does team Spiderman count? no? ok well im team Jacob then.

report

by wishuponastar97 on 11/13/2012 6:19:06 PM

 
 

Team Rob. He HATES Twilight (and Edward) with a burning passion. It's amazing. XD

report

by Dawnstar on 11/13/2012 6:13:49 PM

 
 

TEAM EDWARD
Of course
Jacob is creepy and a jerk
Edward is great
Go Edward
BOOOO Frown Jacob

report

by mozerlou on 11/13/2012 6:06:24 PM

 
 

Team Harry Potter.

report

by tcs789 on 11/13/2012 5:48:40 PM

 
 

Team Edward forever! okay, it WAS super creepy that he watched her while she slept, but Jacon was SO unfair in Eclipse when he manipulated Bella into kissing him, saying he was going to kill himself if she didn't! Who does that?!

report

by livvirox12 on 11/13/2012 5:43:52 PM

 
 

I was Team Jacob, but then he forced a kiss on her in Eclipse. But I'm not Team Edward either because even though he just wants to protect her, he comes off as pretty condescending. Not to mention that he watched her sleep when he barely knew her; that's pretty creepy. But honestly, we all knew that she was going to choose him from the beginning. I don't know about you guys, but the only character I really like is Alice, so I'm Team Alice. Sorry if I offend anyone, that's just my own personal opinion,

report

by Idealgirl04 on 11/13/2012 5:42:30 PM

 
 

I am totally on team Edward! He's super romantic and sweet. Besides, Bella picked him after all!!

report

by miley13t on 11/13/2012 5:36:14 PM

 
 

In the book, Edward is the perfect package (besides ditching Bella for that one time) and Jacob seems like the creepy younger boy that is super obsessed with her. But in the movies, Edward seems like he is a total weirdo and cold and distant, and he is soooooo jealous!!!!!! but Jacob seems like the perfect gentleman and is sooooo hot Smile so I guess I'm on both teams.

report

by actress12345 on 11/13/2012 5:26:36 PM

 
 

jacob

report

by aki2000 on 11/13/2012 5:18:38 PM

 
 

JACOB JACOB JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean who wouldn't want a hot werewolf for a boyfriend? He can protect, help, understand, and love Bella way more than Edward would. Also think of the cute little werewolf babies.

report

by kenziebieber7 on 11/13/2012 5:06:47 PM

 
 

it's really hard to choose between so for the movies i pick jacob but in the the books i pick edward!!

report

by saphiresyphira on 11/13/2012 5:05:44 PM

 
 

Totally team Edward! Though I'm really close to being torn just like GL, I would love a protective bf like that. But Jacob is TOTALLY ADORABLE!!!!! Wow, I just talked myself into being torn :/

report

by turnonthemusic1 on 11/13/2012 4:07:17 PM

 
 

Team Jacob all the way! Bella wouldn't even be thinking about Jake if she was truly and completely in love with Edward. I agree with snoopygalvin, Jacob looks sooooooooooo much better than Edward in the movies! And I love wolves so, JACOB

report

by Dramagirl88 on 11/13/2012 3:05:50 PM

 
 

Team Jacob!! He is amazing <3 and super hot!! <333

report

by *Kailey* on 11/13/2012 2:55:37 PM

 
 

As much as I LOVE Jacob... I think Edward is suited for Bella. I feel like Edward would do ANYTHING for Bella... He was willing to die for Bella! How sweet is that. As much as I hate saying this... Team Edward.


I am so sorry Jacob...

report

by fresnobee on 11/13/2012 2:54:48 PM

 
 

Team.Jacob.No.Question.

report

by Justmecheyenne on 11/13/2012 2:31:55 PM

 
 

How about Team Guy Who Almost Ran Over Bella With His Van?


Yes,I'm a chick yet I don't like Twilight..too much purple prose for me.

report

by Kitty99369936 on 11/13/2012 1:26:27 PM

 
 

Team Jacob! Nothing's cuter than a werewolf:especially as your boyfriend.

report

by ilovehorses224 on 11/13/2012 1:15:12 PM

 
 

Team Jacob!!!!!

report

by wildstar19 on 11/13/2012 12:25:23 PM

 
 

I'm definitely Team Edward. My aunt got me into Twilight over the summer and I started watching the movies afterwards. In the books, Edward is just a guy that you can't not love. He's ridiculously sweet, he does anything for Bella, protects her no matter what and is always by her side. He's even willing to give her up, a girl he loves so much, just if she would be happier with Jacob. In the books and movies, Edward is my choice. <3

report

by Princess Keziyah on 11/13/2012 11:23:26 AM

 
 

Totally team Edward! Even though jacob is cuter, how can I have him if she does? ;) And besides, Edward and Bella have a looovvveee connection. Btw: they both have anger issues!
So sorry that this message is so very confusing! Smile

report

by Rosiegrl on 11/13/2012 9:14:07 AM

 
 

Team Edward!!!!! Even though I think Jacob is cutest. I still love Edward and how he cares so much more for Bella

report

by Gracie206 on 11/13/2012 9:06:12 AM

 
 

Team Jacob! Edward is too protective, he acts like he's her dad or something.

report

by sarabieber1799 on 11/13/2012 8:59:18 AM

 
 

TEAM JACOB!!!!! DUH ;)

report

by gunqueen2000 on 11/13/2012 8:20:22 AM

 
 

Team Edward all the way! He said he would love Bella forever, and Bella just doesn't love Jake as much as Edward. Though both of them have turned their backs on her, Edward did it to protect her. Jacob turned his back so he could be with his werewolf buds. :/

report

by the_girl_in_goal on 11/13/2012 7:49:26 AM

 
 

Team Me!

report

by BriannaM911 on 11/13/2012 7:33:09 AM

 
 

I am on team Edward, and GL should join in because Edward is the one that Bella really loves, she has sort of convinced herself that she loves Jacob too, but really she just loves him as a friend, and also, Edward left because he was trying to protect Bella from himself, because that is how much he cares about her; it was never really a choice for me, it was pretty obvious the whole time who Bella would choose.

report

by otter77 on 11/13/2012 7:16:32 AM

 
 

My comment is that in the movies, they make Jake look better than Edward. in the book you want to choose Edward over Jake

report

by snoopygalvin on 11/13/2012 6:41:01 AM

 
 

Total team JACOB!!!

report

by Lex1 on 11/13/2012 12:46:41 AM

 
 

Team Edward because although Jacob is hotter, Edward cares about Bella more than Jacob does. He would do anything for her and in the books, it is said that Edward's vulnerability is Bella.

report

by Emilicious on 11/13/2012 12:40:13 AM

 
You must be signed in to post a comment. SIGN IN or REGISTER

ADD A COMMENT


 

 

 

  • RENEW
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • GIVE A GIFT
  • DIGITAL EDITIONS
  • ACCOUNT STATUS
 
Monday again? Sigh. What kind of student are you?



 
 
WIN
TODAY
GRAND
PRIZE
GIVEAWAY
CALENDAR
Strawberry Watermelon

Flavor: This fruity combo of two all-time best-selling flavors makes a delightfully sweet treat.

Fab Fact: In 2001, Lip Smacker blended two of its best-selling glosses.

Accomplish your dreams! Gabrielle Douglas tells ya how in Raising the Bar. CLICK HERE to win a copy

Take the 30 Day Craft Challenge!

So what are you going to make today? Try a daily DIY to win cool crafting gear from
My Friendship Bracelet Maker.
 
CLICK HERE to enter!
 
Posts From Our Friends

sponsored links

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Home
  • Free Newsletters
  • Subscribe
  • Give a Gift
  • Renew

  • Model for GL
  • Pay Bill
  • Questions?
  • Contact Us
  • © 2013 Girls' Life Acquisition Co. All Rights Reserved.